Muckle retains IIP Gold with industry leading scores
The North East independent law firm for businesses has stuck gold again with the renowned assessment...
I first became interested in crowdfunding when I wrote my University dissertation on the legislative framework in the UK and US at that time. Broadly speaking I was attempting to give a view on whether the legislation was fit for purpose (to surmise, it wasn't) and could accommodate the growth in demand for crowdfunding. I have followed the growth of Crowdfunding since then, which in 2017 had grown to an estimated £6.2bn in the UK, according to the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance.
I have been most pleased by the growth of its use by Small and Medium Sized Enterprises (SMEs) and start-ups seeking external investment. The UK is heavily reliant on SMEs, who made up 52% of all private sector turnover in 2018 and 60% of all private sector employment. The number of start-up businesses in the North East (where I and many of my WBD colleagues are based) is growing at one of the fastest rates in the country - there were 45,498 start-up businesses in the North East at the end of the 2017/18 financial year, an increase of 20.8% compared to the previous year.
These companies are more and more often looking at Crowdfunding as a method of solving a perceived lack of external financing (known as the 'funding gap') available for such companies. Whilst the factual evidence surrounding the existence of the 'funding gap' is not conclusive, the rules on alternative external funding can be hugely important to such businesses, potentially unlocking the investment to get them through those "touch and go" initial years.
In the UK the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), regulates two forms of crowdfunding:
The FCA has recently launched various consultations on changes to the FCA Handbook to reflect the developments in the crowdfunding sector. The Treasury and BEIS have also focused their attention on the sector, undertaking an inquiry in 2018 on the state of SME finance, with particular consideration of crowdfunding. These enquiries have often focused on similar themes, such as:
Importantly, the FCA has, following these various reviews, confirmed its proposals for new rules and guidance coming into force on 9 December 2019. They are introducing a package of rules and guidance to improve standards, seeking to find an "appropriate balance between advancing policy objectives and enabling future innovation in products and services". These rules, whilst targeted at the P2P and Crowdfunding platforms themselves, could have an impact on the extent to which SMEs rely on some form of crowdfunding to raise money, and such companies should be taking notice.
What is changing?
The changes introduced by the new rules extend the application of the marketing restrictions that currently apply to investment-based crowdfunding platforms to loan based crowdfunding. In particular the FCA is to tighten the nature and extent of the due diligence each platform undertakes in respect of prospective borrowers, in order to better assess their credit risk. The platforms will need to provide more information to investors of how the loan risk is assessed and to assist them in determining whether they able to properly make such investments.
Further to this, P2P platforms that communicate financial promotions directly to consumers will, from 9 December, only be permitted to direct such promotions to prospective investors that:
What is the potential impact on SMEs?
These changes are clearly targeted at protecting potential investors and this is important if the crowdfunding market is to remain a reputable source of raising finance. Crowdfunding has understandably come under greater scrutiny since the FCA forced P2P investor Lendy into administration, and lessons should of course be learnt from this. Critics of the new rules have however raised the view that these regulations may put off investors who would otherwise have provided a source of financing to those companies that need it most, and restrict crowdfunding to institutional investors such as mutual funds, pension funds, banks and asset managers.
My view is that the additional hurdle of certification outlined above is not necessarily a significant barrier to prospective investors. The inclusion of the "restricted investor" criteria is an important one, without which the pool of prospective investors would become much smaller and crowdfunding would become far less accessible to new investors - certified high-net-worth investors and sophisticated investors are concepts generally seen as restrictive and it can often be difficult to find persons who are willing to certify as such. On the other hand a "restricted investor" simply needs to confirm that they will not invest more than 10% of their assets. The FCA has also stated in its policy statement on the new rules that investors can re-classify as sophisticated investors (thereby removing the 10% investment limit) when they have made two or more P2P/Crowdfunding investments over two years.
What is more difficult to assess is whether the due diligence each platform undertakes in practice in respect of prospective borrowers, in order to ensure compliance with the new regulations, will result in an increased burden upon prospective borrowers. A borrower will likely be required to work more closely with the platforms in the run up to their crowdfunding project and this could make crowdfunding less attractive to start-ups and SMEs, if it requires a greater allocation of their (already limited) resources.
For full information on the new rules, please see the FCA's Policy Statement, which can be found at: https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/policy-statements/ps19-14-loan-based-peer-to-peer-investment-based-crowdfunding-platforms-feedback-final-rules
David Ridley is a solicitor in the corporate team at Womble Bond Dickinson (WBD). David first took an interest in crowdfunding at University, having written his dissertation on whether the legislative framework at that time was fit for the predicted exponential growth in crowdfunding. He released a number of articles on the subject in 2015 and 2016, most notably writing the article "Will New Regulation on Crowdfunding in the United Kingdom and United States Have a Positive Impact and Lead to Crowdfunding Becoming an Established Financing Technique?", which was published in the Statute Law Review.
Within WBD David works with clients across a number of sectors, predominantly focusing on corporate transactional work including mergers and acquisitions, private equity investments, joint ventures and MBOs. David also deals with group reorganisations and shareholder arrangements.
Womble Bond Dickinson is a transatlantic law firm with more than 1,000 lawyers based in 27 UK and US office locations. The firm provides core legal services including: Commercial, Corporate, Employment, Pensions, Dispute Resolution, Litigation, Finance, Banking, Restructuring, Insolvency, IP, Technology and Data, Private Wealth, Projects, Construction and Infrastructure, Real Estate and Regulatory Law.
Womble Bond Dickinson has a particular focus on eleven key sectors: Energy & Natural Resources, Financial Institutions, Healthcare, Insurance, Manufacturing, Real Estate, Retail & Consumer, Transport, Logistics & Infrastructure, Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology & Life Sciences, Technology and Private Wealth.
The firm’s UK offices are in Aberdeen, Bristol, Edinburgh, Leeds, London, Newcastle, Plymouth and Southampton. The US offices are in Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Houston, Los Angeles, Orange County, Palo Alto, Silicon Valley - Calif, Wilmington - Del, Charlotte, Greensboro, Raleigh, Research Triangle Park, Winston-Salem - N.C., Charleston, Columbia, Greenville - S.C., Charlottesville, Tysons Corner - Va. and Washington D.C.
The firm's reach also extends to Europe where it has strategic partnerships with other law firms in Germany and France. Through the firm’s association with Lex Mundi, the world’s largest association of independent law firms, Womble Bond Dickinson also can offer clients access to quality-tested local counsel in more than 120 countries.